Blog cover image
Laborhutt Staff
June 23, 2024

Budget Breakdown: Pickup Truck Rental Compared to Hiring Movers

To rent a pickup truck or hire movers?" It's a common dilemma for anyone moving.  Everyone wants to save money. Moving can be costly. But the price difference between renting a pickup truck and hiring movers can vary a lot. Understanding these factors can help you decide the best option. 


Breaking Down Costs: Pickup Truck Rentals

The data below gives you a table of the expenses to expect when renting a pickup truck.

pickup truck rental prices

Renting a pickup truck is often seen as a cheaper option, especially for smaller moves or transporting specific items like furniture, storage moves, and more.

Here are a few key considerations to keep in mind:

  • Rental Costs:

    Pickup trucks generally have a lower initial rental fee compared to hiring a moving service. However, it's important to factor in additional costs such as fuel, potential mileage fees, and insurance.

  • Flexibility and Control:

    Renting a pickup truck allows you to control your schedule and pace. You're not reliant on a moving company's availability and can make multiple trips if needed.

  • Physical Effort:

    Keep in mind that renting a truck means you'll be doing the heavy lifting. Assess your physical ability and whether you have enough helping hands to move larger items.

  • Distance:

    For local moves, a pickup truck can be highly economical. For longer distances, renting a truck might incur additional costs that could make professional movers more appealing.

  • Insurance and Liability:

    Understand the insurance options available. Truck rental companies often offer coverage plans, but it's crucial to check your personal auto insurance policy and credit card benefits for potential protections as well.

"When planning your move, consider the scale of your relocation, the distance involved, and your circumstances. This will help you weigh the financial benefits and practicalities of renting a pickup truck versus hiring professional movers."

When Renting a Pickup Truck Makes Sense

Opting to rent a pickup truck can be a savvy choice in several scenarios. If your move involves a relatively small load, such as relocating a studio apartment's worth of items or moving furniture locally, a pickup truck would be a better option.

Renting a pickup truck also allows you more flexibility.

You can move at your own pace without the pressure of working within the rigid schedule often associated with hiring professional movers. Another clear advantage is the cost-effectiveness—you only pay for the time you need the vehicle, and with daily costs often around $100, it's a manageable expense, particularly for smaller, shorter moves.

Renting a pickup truck for local moves

If you're moving within 50 miles, renting a pickup truck can be a cheaper option. You’ll typically find rental rates ranging from $30 to $250, influenced by factors such as the truck's size and the duration of your rental. While these figures represent a marked saving compared to hiring a moving company, it’s important to consider additional expenses that may arise.

These extra costs include fuel, which can add up quickly depending on the distance you're traveling and the fuel efficiency of the truck. Furthermore, you might need to budget for food and lodging if your move spans more than a day, ensuring you and any helpers remain well-rested and fed.

Don't forget the necessity of specialized moving equipment. Renting items like dollies, furniture pads, and tie-down straps will make the process smoother and protect your belongings, but they do come at an extra cost. If you already own these tools or can borrow them, you can save even more money.

Renting a Pickup Truck: What to Expect

Renting a pickup truck is usually cheaper than hiring professional movers. You’ll pay a daily rental fee plus mileage charges. This can be more affordable, especially for short distances.

  • Base Rental Rate: This is the daily fee for using the truck.

  • Mileage Fees: Companies charge per mile driven, which can add up for long distances.

  • Fuel Costs: You’ll need to refuel the truck before returning it, so consider how far you'll drive and gas prices.

While renting a truck can save money, you’ll need to pack, load, and unload yourself, which can be tiring.

Breaking Down Costs: Hiring Movers

Hiring moves cost breakdown

When you hire professional movers, you're paying for convenience and expertise. Here's what your money goes toward:

  • Labor:

    This is the main cost. Companies charge by the hour to load, transport, and unload your items.

  • Fuel:

    You'll cover the truck's fuel. Some companies include this in their hourly rate, while others list it separately.

  • Materials:

    This includes the cost of boxes, tape, and padding. It's usually part of the overall price.

  • Equipment:

    Movers use dollies, straps, and blankets to move your items safely. The cost for these tools is typically included.

The average cost of hiring movers depends on several factors. Distance, the amount of stuff you have, and extra services (like packing) matter. A local move might cost $500 to $1,500, while a long-distance move can be $2,000 to $5,000 or more.

Many moving companies have cost calculators on their websites to help you estimate the price. This tool is great for budgeting and comparing quotes.

If you want to save money, consider hiring inexpensive movers. They might charge less but offer fewer services. You could save big by packing your items yourself.

Also, tipping movers is a common practice. The guideline is to tip $20 per person for a half-day move and $40 per person for a full-day move. Adjust this based on their and service quality move's the difficulty.

To save even more, pack your own boxes, ask friends and family for help, and use free or recycled packing materials. Always compare quotes from different companies to get the best deal for your budget.

Hiring a Mover: What to Expect

Hiring a moving company is convenient. Movers handle all the heavy lifting, packing, and transportation. It's usually more expensive but saves you stress and effort. Costs depend on several factors:

  • Distance:

    Long-distance moves cost more.

  • Volume of Items:

    More items mean higher costs. Movers may charge by weight or volume.

  • Additional Services:

    Packing, insurance, and handling delicate items add to the cost.

Hiring professionals means your items are insured against damage, which adds peace of mind.

In conclusion, whether you rent a truck or hire movers, consider all costs and what you are comfortable with.

Situations Where Hiring Movers is More Practical

Sometimes, hiring movers isn't just a luxury but a necessity. For instance, if you don't have much time, movers can be a huge help. Imagine you only have a weekend to move your whole house; movers can take care of packing, loading, transporting, and unloading.

Hiring movers also makes sense when you have big, heavy, or delicate items.

They have the skills and tools to move things like pianos, antiques, and large appliances safely. Without them, you might damage your stuff or property.

Another good reason to hire movers is for long-distance or international moves.

These moves can be really complicated. Professional movers know how to handle these challenges, saving you stress and problems.

If you have health issues or physical limitations, movers are the safer choice.

Moving is hard work and can be risky, even if you're in good health. Professionals can do the heavy lifting for you, reducing the risk of injury.

Supporting data & sources:

Average cost to rent a pickup truck for a day: $19.95 - $29.95

Additional mileage fees for pickup truck rental: $0.59 - $0.79 per mile

Average cost of hiring professional movers: $80 - $100 per hour

Average distance moved within the same city: 10 - 20 miles

Cost of moving supplies (boxes, tape, etc.): $50 - $100

Insurance coverage for rental trucks: $15 - $30 per day


Welcome to  LaborHutt.com!

Looking for moving help? Laborhutt makes moving furniture & heavy items a breeze by connecting you with neighbors who have pickup trucks. Message a neighbor near you and save time and money.